Policy Impact Analysis - 117/S/5077

Bill Overview

Title: A bill to amend the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act to provide that Alexander Creek, Incorporated, is recognized as a Village Corporation under that Act, and for other purposes.

Description: This bill recognizes Alexander Creek, Incorporated, as an Alaska Native village corporation, subject to certain conditions, and Alexander Creek village as an Alaska Native village. Alexander Creek, Incorporated, must submit to the Department of the Interior any amendments to its state corporate charter that are necessary to convert from a group corporation to a village corporation. The bill requires Interior to offer to enter into negotiations with Alexander Creek, Incorporated, to settle aboriginal land claims and any other claims against the United States. As a condition of recognition as a village corporation, Alexander Creek, Incorporated must enter into such an agreement with Interior no later than 13 months after this bill's enactment. Alexander Creek, Incorporated, must notify its members that (1) they will cease to receive benefits from Cook Inlet Region, Incorporated, individually as at-large shareholders, and (2) all future resource payments shall be retained by Alexander Creek, Incorporated.

Sponsors: Sen. Sullivan, Dan [R-AK]

Target Audience

Population: Members and shareholders of Alexander Creek, Incorporated

Estimated Size: 200

Reasoning

Simulated Interviews

Fisherwoman (Alexander Creek, Alaska)

Age: 45 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 20.0 years

Commonness: 5/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Recognition as a village corporation feels like taking control of our future.
  • I am worried about losing dividends from the Cook Inlet Region, Inc.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 7 6
Year 2 8 6
Year 3 8 6
Year 5 8 5
Year 10 9 5
Year 20 9 4

Retired (Anchorage, Alaska)

Age: 62 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 5

Duration of Impact: 15.0 years

Commonness: 7/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Losing income from Cook Inlet Region worries me, but it’s important to secure land rights.
  • Unsure if Alexander Creek will manage resources effectively.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 5 5
Year 2 6 5
Year 3 6 4
Year 5 6 4
Year 10 7 3
Year 20 6 3

Small business owner (Alexander Creek, Alaska)

Age: 33 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 7

Duration of Impact: 20.0 years

Commonness: 4/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Increased local control should boost the economy, thus helping my business.
  • I'm excited about the possible land negotiations.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 8 7
Year 2 9 7
Year 3 9 6
Year 5 9 6
Year 10 10 5
Year 20 9 5

Environmental Scientist (Fairbanks, Alaska)

Age: 29 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 10.0 years

Commonness: 8/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • It provides an exciting opportunity for the community to assert autonomy.
  • I hope that resource management is done sustainably.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 6 6
Year 2 6 6
Year 3 7 6
Year 5 7 6
Year 10 8 6
Year 20 7 5

Corporate Executive (Seattle, Washington)

Age: 52 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 9

Duration of Impact: 0.0 years

Commonness: 10/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Not directly impacted, but I do business with native cooperations occasionally.
  • I hope it leads to more cooperation opportunities.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 9 9
Year 2 9 9
Year 3 9 9
Year 5 9 9
Year 10 9 9
Year 20 9 9

Activist (Los Angeles, California)

Age: 38 | Gender: other

Wellbeing Before Policy: 7

Duration of Impact: 5.0 years

Commonness: 6/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • It's a positive step towards self-determination.
  • Hope that it sets a precedent for other communities.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 7 7
Year 2 7 7
Year 3 8 7
Year 5 8 7
Year 10 8 7
Year 20 8 7

Student (Alexander Creek, Alaska)

Age: 19 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 20.0 years

Commonness: 9/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • As a young person, this recognition could improve future job prospects.
  • I worry about how older family members will adjust.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 7 6
Year 2 7 6
Year 3 8 6
Year 5 8 6
Year 10 9 6
Year 20 8 5

Teacher (Juneau, Alaska)

Age: 55 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 8

Duration of Impact: 15.0 years

Commonness: 5/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Cultural empowerment is key for educational engagement.
  • I hope benefits reach the village efficiently.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 8 8
Year 2 8 8
Year 3 8 7
Year 5 9 7
Year 10 9 7
Year 20 9 7

Engineer (Houston, Texas)

Age: 41 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 5

Duration of Impact: 0.0 years

Commonness: 11/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • No direct impact, but potential changes in regional resource management could affect business.
  • Supportive of indigenous claims.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 5 5
Year 2 5 5
Year 3 5 5
Year 5 5 5
Year 10 5 5
Year 20 5 5

Retired Elder (Alexander Creek, Alaska)

Age: 67 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 4

Duration of Impact: 20.0 years

Commonness: 4/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • The shift might strain my immediate financial security, but it's reassuring to have more local authority.
  • I hope our land and traditions are protected.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 5 4
Year 2 6 4
Year 3 6 3
Year 5 7 3
Year 10 7 2
Year 20 7 2

Cost Estimates

Year 1: $5000000 (Low: $3000000, High: $8000000)

Year 2: $2000000 (Low: $1500000, High: $4000000)

Year 3: $1000000 (Low: $500000, High: $2000000)

Year 5: $500000 (Low: $200000, High: $1000000)

Year 10: $0 (Low: $0, High: $500000)

Year 100: $0 (Low: $0, High: $0)

Key Considerations