Policy Impact Analysis - 117/HR/7744

Bill Overview

Title: Building America’s Health Care Workforce Act

Description: This bill extends certain flexibilities relating to training and competency requirements for nurse aides in Medicare skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) and Medicaid nursing facilities (NFs). Generally, SNFs and NFs may not hire nurse aides for longer than four months unless they meet certain training and certification requirements. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services waived some of these requirements during the COVID-19 emergency period so as to allow facilities to maintain adequate staffing levels; the waiver ends in June 2022. The bill extends these flexibilities for at least two years after the bill's enactment and specifies that (1) any time worked by a nurse aide during the emergency period counts toward the 75 hours required for initial training, and (2) a competency evaluation may be conducted at the SNF or NF where the nurse aide is employed if the state does not offer such an evaluation at least once a week.

Sponsors: Rep. Guthrie, Brett [R-KY-2]

Target Audience

Population: Nurse aides in SNFs and NFs around the world

Estimated Size: 300000

Reasoning

Simulated Interviews

Nurse Aide (Chicago, IL)

Age: 45 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 5

Duration of Impact: 2.0 years

Commonness: 16/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • I started this job out of necessity during the pandemic and have been able to stay due to the flexibility allowed.
  • This bill will allow me to gain permanent certification while continuing to work, which removes a load of stress from my life.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 6 5
Year 2 7 5
Year 3 7 5
Year 5 8 6
Year 10 8 6
Year 20 7 6

Nursing Facility Administrator (Rural Tennessee)

Age: 55 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 4

Duration of Impact: 5.0 years

Commonness: 12/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Retaining qualified nurse aides has been a major challenge, particularly after the waiver period.
  • This policy could allow me to maintain adequate staffing which is essential for patient care at our facility.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 5 4
Year 2 6 4
Year 3 6 3
Year 5 7 4
Year 10 7 5
Year 20 6 5

Nurse Aide Trainee (Phoenix, AZ)

Age: 29 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 2.0 years

Commonness: 15/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Job security during this training process makes a huge difference to someone like me.
  • I believe this policy would make the transition from trainee to a permanent position smoother.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 7 6
Year 2 7 6
Year 3 7 6
Year 5 8 7
Year 10 8 7
Year 20 7 7

Retired Veteran (Miami, FL)

Age: 67 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 7

Duration of Impact: 3.0 years

Commonness: 11/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • The staff turnover has been a real concern for us residents here.
  • Having the same aides around makes a big difference in the comfort and care we receive.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 8 7
Year 2 8 7
Year 3 7 7
Year 5 8 7
Year 10 8 7
Year 20 7 6

State Health Official (New York, NY)

Age: 42 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 5

Duration of Impact: 10.0 years

Commonness: 6/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • This extension could simplify a lot of our transitional processes, but we need to ensure competencies are still being met.
  • It’s an opportunity for us to rethink training and certification to meet future needs.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 6 5
Year 2 6 5
Year 3 7 5
Year 5 8 6
Year 10 8 6
Year 20 8 6

Nurse Aide (Los Angeles, CA)

Age: 34 | Gender: other

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 3.0 years

Commonness: 14/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Certification holds have meant I couldn’t take on more hours or a full-time role, which affects my income.
  • This policy would help turn my experience into valid certification and full-time work.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 8 6
Year 2 8 6
Year 3 7 5
Year 5 8 5
Year 10 9 5
Year 20 8 5

Healthcare Economist (Houston, TX)

Age: 50 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 3.0 years

Commonness: 4/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • This bill highlights the importance of quick recruiting during emergencies, but we must ensure it truly enhances service quality long-term.
  • Spending and training flexibility are crucial, but there needs to be a focus on monitoring competency outcomes cut across states.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 6 6
Year 2 7 6
Year 3 7 6
Year 5 7 7
Year 10 7 7
Year 20 7 6

Nurse Aid Educator (Seattle, WA)

Age: 49 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 5.0 years

Commonness: 8/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • The policy could diversify our training offerings and attract more nurse aide students longer term.
  • We should incorporate on-site evaluations more frequently, which this policy supports.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 6 6
Year 2 7 6
Year 3 8 6
Year 5 8 6
Year 10 8 7
Year 20 8 6

Nursing Student (Minneapolis, MN)

Age: 26 | Gender: male

Wellbeing Before Policy: 5

Duration of Impact: 2.0 years

Commonness: 10/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Knowing there are more avenues open to aid practice could influence my career decisions.
  • It might help gain experience faster, given the extended timelines to certification while working.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 6 5
Year 2 7 5
Year 3 7 5
Year 5 8 6
Year 10 9 6
Year 20 8 6

Family Member of SNF Resident (Denver, CO)

Age: 39 | Gender: female

Wellbeing Before Policy: 6

Duration of Impact: 3.0 years

Commonness: 9/20

Statement of Opinion:

  • Quality and consistency in care are vital, and policy changes affecting nurse aides can indirectly change the nature of care received by residents.
  • I worry whether the policy ensures continued competence in caregiving roles, but do appreciate the staffing flexibility.

Wellbeing Over Time (With vs Without Policy)

Year With Policy Without Policy
Year 1 6 6
Year 2 7 6
Year 3 6 6
Year 5 7 6
Year 10 7 6
Year 20 6 6

Cost Estimates

Year 1: $10000000 (Low: $7000000, High: $15000000)

Year 2: $9000000 (Low: $6000000, High: $14000000)

Year 3: $0 (Low: $0, High: $0)

Year 5: $0 (Low: $0, High: $0)

Year 10: $0 (Low: $0, High: $0)

Year 100: $0 (Low: $0, High: $0)

Key Considerations